Chapter 2 - The Audit of Flesh

The basement of the old Municipal Produce Market on 14th Street smelled of damp limestone, crushed cabbage leaves, and sixty years of engine oil.
It was a cavernous space—four hundred feet long, supported by thick, square concrete pillars painted with peeling yellow industrial enamel. High above, three rows of unshielded, high-pressure sodium lamps hung from steel chains, casting a harsh, orange-yellow light that turned every shadow into a deep, jagged pools of blackness.
In the center of the vast concrete floor sat nine metal folding chairs.
They were arranged in a single line, spaced four feet apart.
Sitting in those chairs, their ankles bound to the steel legs with heavy plastic zip-ties, their hands secured behind their backs with steel police restraints, were Arthur Vane and his eight sons.
They were no longer wearing their leather jackets or their grease-stained boots. They had been stripped down to their grey cotton undershirts and trousers. Their faces were smeared with dirt and grey soot from the transport vans; their lips were dry, cracked, flecked with white foam from hours of screaming behind heavy black duct tape that covered their mouths.
Standing behind them were twelve men in immaculate dark suits. They were silent, their arms crossed over their chests, their faces completely unreadable.
At the far end of the room, sitting behind a small folding card table, was Viktor Koryak. He was drinking tea from a porcelain cup, his silver-headed cane resting against his knee.
I walked down the concrete ramp that led from the street-level loading dock.
My Oxfords made a steady, rhythmic click-clack-click-clack against the floor.
The moment the nine men heard my footsteps, their heads snapped toward me. Thomas began to thrash violently in his chair, his shoulders twisting as he tried to break the heavy plastic ties around his calves. His eyes were wide, bulging, filled with a wild, animal panic.
I did not look at Thomas. I walked to the front of the line and stood before Arthur Vane.
I reached out, took the corner of the black duct tape covering his mouth, and pulled it off in one sudden, sharp jerk.
Arthur let out a ragged, whistling gasp, spitting a mouthful of blood and thick saliva onto the concrete between my shoes.
“Vance!” he croaked. His voice was almost entirely gone, reduced to a dry, rattling whisper. “Vance, listen to me! Listen to me, you crazy bastard! You can't do this! The feds... the feds know where we are! My brother-in-law is a deputy sheriff in the third district!”
“Your brother-in-law was arrested twenty minutes ago at his kitchen table, Arthur,” I said. My voice was calm, almost conversational. I reached into my coat pocket and pulled out a clean, white linen handkerchief. “He was found in possession of four kilograms of unregistered C4 explosives that were traced back to a military armory in Georgia. He will spend the remainder of his natural life in a supermax facility in Florence, Colorado.”
Arthur’s mouth remained open. His chest heaved, his ribcage expanding against the thin cotton of his undershirt.
“You’re a monster,” he spat. “You’re a goddamn devil.”
“No,” I corrected him softly. “I am a logistics manager, Arthur. I organize systems. I balance books. And tonight, I am performing an audit on your life.”
I signaled to one of the suited men standing near the wall.
He stepped forward carrying a heavy leather briefcase. He laid it flat on the card table beside Viktor Koryak, popped the brass latches with two crisp clacks, and lifted the lid.
Inside were nine identical manila folders, each marked with a red rubber stamp across the top edge.
I took the first folder—the one labeled VANE, ARTHUR SR.—and opened it.
“In 2018,” I read aloud, my voice echoing off the damp concrete walls, “you owed ninety-four thousand dollars to a local loan shark named Jimmy ‘The Meat’ Cleary. You couldn't pay. You went to your daughter Clara, who was twenty-four at the time, and you told her that Jimmy’s men were going to burn down her piano studio if she didn't sign a personal loan guarantee.”
Arthur winced. He tried to look away, turning his head toward the dark pillars at the edge of the room.
“Look at me, Arthur,” I said.
He didn't turn.
Viktor Koryak did not move from his chair, but one of the suited men behind Arthur reached down, grabbed Arthur by his thin grey hair, and yanked his head back until his throat was stretched tight against his collar.
“Clara paid that loan,” I continued, turning a page. “She worked sixty hours a week for three years. She gave up her master’s degree at the conservatory. She ate canned soup and drove a car with no heater because she believed she was saving her father from a violent death.”
I looked down at him.
“Jimmy Cleary was not going to burn down her studio, Arthur. Jimmy Cleary was your drinking partner. You used that ninety-four thousand dollars to buy a fifty percent share in an illegal sports-gambling ring operating out of the back room of the West Side Bowling Alley. A ring that failed within six months.”
“She was my daughter!” Arthur screamed, his eyes rolling back in his head as the guard held his hair. “A daughter owes her father! I raised her! I fed her!”
“You beat her mother until the woman died of an untreated brain aneurysm when Clara was eleven,” I said.
The room went completely silent.
Even the eight brothers stopped thrashing. Thomas’s chest stopped moving; he stared at his father with a look of slow, horrifying realization.
“I have the medical records from 2007, Arthur,” I said, turning to the third page of the file. “Dr. Arisneau at the community clinic knew what happened. He was paid eight thousand dollars by your brother to mark the cause of death as an accidental fall in the bathtub. I bought Dr. Arisneau’s medical license three years ago. I have his signed confession locked in my safe in Manhattan.”
I closed the folder with a soft thud.
“You are not a patriarch, Arthur. You are a tapeworm. You fed on your wife until she died, and then you turned your teeth on your daughter.”
I stepped sideways, stopping in front of Thomas—the eldest brother.
I reached out and ripped the duct tape from his lips.
Thomas didn't scream. He began to weep. It was a pathetic, unmanly sound—a wet, sniveling blubber that sent trails of snot running down over his thick upper lip.
“Julian... Julian, please,” Thomas sobbed, his knees shaking against the steel chair legs. “It was Dad! It was all Dad! He told us to do it! He said Clara was going to give the land to you and we’d get nothing! He said you were a weak little bitch who wouldn't do anything about it!”
“Thomas,” I said gently. “You were thirty-four years old tonight. You weigh two hundred and twenty pounds. You hold a black belt in amateur wrestling.”
“I’m sorry! I’m sorry, Julian! God, please, I have two kids! I have little Tommy and Sarah!”
“Your children were removed from your home at two o'clock this morning by Child Protective Services,” I informed him, my tone completely neutral. “They have been placed in the custody of a high-ranking family law judge in Greenwich who has already initiated full, irrevocable adoption proceedings. They will be raised in a home with six acres of meadow, three horses, and a mother who has never seen a bottle of cheap rye in her life. By the time they are seven years old, they will not remember your name.”
Thomas let out a high-pitched, animal shriek, dropping his chin toward his chest as his frame collapsed into violent, uncontrollable convulsions.
I opened the second folder.
“Thomas Vane,” I read. “Three convictions for felony assault, all dismissed due to altered police evidence provided by your precinct captain. Six separate reports of domestic violence filed by your ex-wife, all buried by the city records department.”
I closed the folder and tossed it onto the floor at his feet.
“You are a broken tool, Thomas. A blunt instrument used by a pathetic man to enforce his small, pathetic will.”
I turned to Viktor Koryak.
“Viktor,” I said.
The old Russian set his porcelain tea cup down on its saucer with a delicate clink. He stood up, resting his heavy weight on his silver-headed stick.
“Yes, my friend?” Viktor asked.
“The harbor facilities in Vladivostok need labor for the heavy ore loading docks,” I said. “The cold season is beginning next week. I understand the mortality rate for unregistered, non-citizen workers in the salt mines is quite high.”
Viktor smiled. It was a cold, grey expression that showed a line of small, perfectly straight steel teeth.
“The salt mines in Kamchatka are currently operating at thirty percent capacity, Julian,” Viktor said softly. “The water there is very hard. A man who works twelve hours a day in the brine usually loses his teeth within six months. His lungs last perhaps two years if he is strong.”
“No!” Arthur roared from his chair, his body twisting against his restraints. “No! You can't do this! You’re a civilian! You’re a nobody! You can't just send citizens to Russia!”
I walked back to Arthur. I knelt down until my eyes were level with his.
“Arthur,” I said, my voice barely above a whisper. “You spent sixty years believing that the world was divided into men with guns and men with calculators. You thought that because you could swing a hammer and smash a piece of drywall, you were dangerous.”
I reached out and lightly tapped my finger against his chest, right over his heart.
“The men with guns work for the men with calculators, Arthur. They always have. The world you lived in was a cage I built for you, and tonight, I am simply turning off the heat.”
I stood up, pulling my charcoal jacket flat once more.
“Take the brothers to the docks,” I instructed Viktor’s men. “Put them on the bulk freighter Karl Marx. They sail at four AM.”
“And the father?” Viktor asked, pointing his silver cane at Arthur.
I looked at Arthur Vane one last time.
“Leave him here,” I said.
Arthur’s eyes widened with a sudden, desperate hope. “You’re... you’re letting me go?”
“No, Arthur,” I said, turning my back on him and walking toward the concrete exit ramp. “I’m leaving you with Chief Vance. He has forty-eight hours of tape recordings from your auto shop regarding the disappearance of three young women in 2012. You will spend the rest of your nights in a eight-by-ten cell in the state penitentiary, surrounded by men who know exactly what you did to your daughter.”
May you like
As I stepped out into the cold, rain-slicked alleyway behind the produce market, the heavy iron door slammed shut behind me.
The last sound I heard before the lock turned was the high, screaming wail of Arthur Vane as the lights in the basement were turned off one by one.