Newshub
Dec 13, 2025

Supreme Court: ‘Thousands’ Of Inmates Denied Chance At Shorter Sentences-llllllllllllllllllll

On Friday, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled against a drug dealer. This meant that thousands of federal prisoners who were trying to get their sentences cut would have to wait longer.

The court, which had a rare ideological split of 6-3, said Mark Pulsifer, who admitted to selling methamphetamines in 2020, could not use a part of the First Step Act, which is a major law that changes how sentences are given.

The question at hand was whether Pulsifer should have to serve 15 years in prison or be able to get a “safety valve” provision. It says that nonviolent, low-level drug offenders could get a lighter sentence under certain circumstances, according to the news source.

In a decision by liberal Justice Elena Kagan, the court said that Pulsifer did not meet the requirements. Five of the six conservative justices on the court agreed with her and voted for her.

The part in question lays out a set of rules for giving sentences that are shorter than the minimums that are required by law. The court said Pulsifer had to meet all the requirements and didn’t agree with his argument that meeting some criteria would be enough to get relief. The decision was partly based on how the court understood the word “and,” the news source said.

Kagan wrote that Congress “did not give safety-valve relief to all defendants, but only to some.” Sonia Sotomayor and Ketanji Brown Jackson, the two liberal justices who were still on the bench, joined Neil Gorsuch, the conservative justice, in disagreeing.

Gorsuch said that the high court put a lot of limits on the First Step Act’s goal.

“Adopting the government’s preferred interpretation guarantees that thousands more people in the federal justice system will be denied a chance — just a chance — at an individualized sentence. For them, the First Step Act offers no hope.”

Meanwhile, the Supreme Court dealt another blow to Gov. Greg Abbott’s efforts to secure his state’s border with Mexico after years of dealing with migrant surges thanks to President Joe Biden’s lack of enforcement.

Other posts