Chapter 4 - The Mirror

By the time Sadie was three months old, the winter snow had settled heavily over Ohio.
The days were short, dark, and freezing.
Caleb’s work hours had increased due to a major bridge inspection project downtown. He was leaving the house at six in the morning and coming home after seven at night, exhausted and stressed.
I was alone with Sadie for fourteen hours a day.
Depression didn't arrive with a loud crash. It arrived quietly, like a thick fog that rolled in under the bedroom door while I was sleeping.
It made my limbs feel heavy. It made simple tasks—like washing a milk bottle or putting on a clean shirt—feel like climbing a mountain.
Every morning, after Caleb left for work, I would lay Sadie on her play mat in the living room and sit on the floor beside her.
I would stare at her face for hours.
I searched every millimeter of her feature.
I looked at the delicate curve of her upper lip. Was that mine? Or was it Caleb’s? I looked at her tiny fingernails. Were they long like my mother’s? Or broad like Marjorie’s? I looked at the way her hair grew at the nape of her neck. Was there any trace of me in her? Any small, quiet secret that belonged exclusively to my bloodline?
Every time I looked in the mirror, I saw nothing.
One Tuesday morning, while Sadie was taking her morning nap, my phone rang.
It was my college friend, Nina. She was an architect living in Chicago, unmarried, childless, and the only person in my life who didn't know the Warren family.
"Hey, mama," Nina’s energetic voice came through the speaker. "How are you surviving the arctic tundra of Columbus?"
I sat at the kitchen island, staring at a cold cup of chamomile tea.
"I'm tired, Nina," I whispered.
Nina’s tone instantly shifted, dropping its playful edge. "Clara? What’s wrong? You sound... really down."
I squeezed my eyes shut, holding the phone tightly against my ear.
"Nina... do you think a mother can love her baby too much, but still feel like she doesn't exist?"
There was a long silence on the line.
"What do you mean?" Nina asked gently.
The words came pouring out of me in a sudden, desperate flood—the weeks of built-up pain, the comments at the hospital, the Facebook posts, Marjorie’s jokes, the feeling of being erased from my own child’s story.
"Everyone looks at her and sees Caleb," I sobbed quietly into the empty kitchen. "His mother, his sister, his friends, even strangers at the grocery store. They look at her and they say, 'Oh, Dad won this one!' Or 'You were just the incubator!' And Nina... when I hold her... sometimes I look at her and I feel like I’m holding someone else’s child. Like I was just a surrogate for the Warren family."
"Oh, Clara..." Nina breathed softly. "Honey, that’s terrible. That is so incredibly unfair."
"I love her so much it hurts," I wept, wiping my nose with the back of my hand. "I would die for her without blinking. But every time someone says she looks nothing like me, it feels like they’re erasing my existence. It feels like they’re saying I didn't matter. Like my body didn't break to bring her here."
"Have you talked to Caleb about this?" Nina asked.
I swallowed hard. "No."
"Why not?"
"Because he doesn't understand," I said softly. "To him, it’s just a compliment. He loves that she looks like him. He’s proud of it. If I tell him how much it hurts me, he’ll think I’m being crazy. He’ll think I’m jealous of my own husband."
"Clara," Nina said firmly. "You are not crazy. You suffered post-partum trauma. You lost your mother. You have no family support system in that town except his relatives. You are carrying a massive emotional load all by yourself. You need to talk to him."
I looked toward the hallway, where Sadie’s baby monitor sat glowing on the counter.
Through the speaker, I could hear her small, rhythmic breathing.
"I can't," I whispered. "If I say it out loud to him, it makes it real. It makes me a terrible mother."
"You are not a terrible mother," Nina insisted fierce. "You are a human being who deserves to be seen."
We hung up twenty minutes later.
I walked back into the living room, stood in front of the large decorative mirror above the fireplace, and pulled Sadie’s month-by-month photo album off the shelf.
I held her three-month photo next to my own face in the reflection.
I stared at the two images.
In the photo, Sadie had wide blue eyes, a tiny chin, and thick brown hair. In the glass, I had hollow grey eyes, pale skin, and limp, dark hair.
May you like
There was no trace of me in her.
The world was right. Caleb had won. I was just the incubator.